Peer Review Process

The Journal of Emerging Trends in Commerce and Leadership (JETCL) seeks to uphold rigor in the academic standards of its published content by ensuring that it goes through a fair, unbiased, and transparent peer review process. Manuscripts submitted are assessed for originality, relevance, quality, validity, and contribution of the field of commerce, business, management, leadership, finance, economics and related areas of research.

Peer Review

JETCL strives to provide fair evaluation of manuscripts submitted to JETCL through a peer review process. The review process of the journal should be clarified in the editorial policy of the journal.

All manuscripts are initially evaluated for submission to the journal, based on suitability of the manuscript for the scope of the journal and for general submission requirements. Manuscripts that fulfill the above requirements can then be submitted to appropriate reviewers who have knowledge of commerce, business and management, leadership, finance, economics, or related fields.

Objectives of Peer Review

The goal of the peer review process is to:

  • ● Ensure academic standards and rigor are upheld.
  • ● Praise research ethics and publication ethics.
  • ● Critically assess original and meaningful research.
  • ● Evaluate manuscripts for scope of the journal.
  • ● Enhance the quality and clarity of manuscripts.
  • ● Give positive comments to writers.
  • ● Make well-informed and unbiased editorial choices.
  • ● Promote ongoing research and development.

Review Criteria

Manuscripts are judged on the basis of:

  • ● Originality and novelty of the work of research.
  • ● Appropriateness to the aims and scope of the journal.
  • ● Quality of the literature review and critical analysis.
  • ● Clarity and consistency of research arguments, and strength.
  • ● Research methodology - appropriateness.
  • ● Correctness and trustworthiness of data, analysis and conclusions.
  • ● Interpretation and discussion: Quality.
  • ● Theoretical or practical contribution of the research.
  • ● Organisation, structure and quality of writing.
  • ● Obedience to relevant ethical standards.
  • ● Overall contribution to commerce, business, management, leadership, finance, economics or related research.

Editorial Decisions

Based on reviewers’ comments and the editor’s assessment, the editor may decide to:

  • ● Accept without revision.
  • ● Accept subject to minor changes.
  • ● Ask for substantial changes and resubmission.
  • ● Reject the manuscript.

If revisions are requested, authors need to resubmit the revised manuscript within the deadline. They should take the comments of the reviewers and the editor into consideration and give a good answer as to what changes were made.

The final publication depends on the academic merit, originality, relevance, appropriateness of the research methodology, content of the results and discussion, and on the comments of the reviewers.

 

JETCL aims to preserve confidentiality, fairness, editorial independence, transparency, research integrity and scholarly excellence in the peer-review process.